1920 Union City, Erie, Pennsylvania 2nd Avenue
Treat Arthur B head 51 New York, New York, New York clothing store mang?
- Katherine R wife 47 Pennsylvania, New York, New York
- Levertt?? son 19
- Gwndoline daughter 22
- Theodore son 17
Reese, Adison stepson 19
- Herbert A stepson 15
-Frederick E? stepson 11

ages of children and step children imply a first marriage for Arthur.

1930 Union City, Erie, Pennsylvania
Treat Arthur B head 6000 61
- Katherine Z wife 58
Zeinder?? Rebecca mother-in-law