Chris Richards Found (John) William Stahl on Google. A genealogy report created by Paul A. Reese, in the family of Elizabeth Reese, (alleged) mother of Christina Stahl. Also listed are all the brother & sisters of Christine (a) Stahl as listed under Charles W Stahl (currently). In our current records, Elizabeth Bachman is mother of Christina Stahl Hoster, but that name may follow her Reese name. Birth information does not agree with current dates . Listed is (John) W Stahl: b. c. 1830 Pennsylvania, d. c. 1880. Elizabeth Reese b 17 Oct. 1813 (Macungie, PA), d. 1889.

Paul Reese Notes < http://genforum.genealogy.com/cgi-bin/pageload.cgi?stahl::ny/niagara::318.html >Results of a few house census searching.

The number after each name is age followed by sex. The 3600 and 500 following for William Stahl is the value of real estate and personal property respectively. The location at the end of each line is the place of birth. I have placed my comments in square brackets. []

My uncle believes that the Stahl's and Reeses knew each other in Mecungie Pa. then both families moved to Niagara county. He believes the Reese family moved in 1831 when Elizabeth Reese Stahl was 17 years old. If Margaret Stahl is the oldest Stahl child ,William Stahl and Elizabeth Reese were perhaps married in 1832 or 1833 shortly after arriving in Niagara County. I am assuming that Williams may have been John W. Stahl.

1860 Census Town of Lockport, Niagara County. pg 230 Line 1857 (1867)
William Stahl 57 M Farmer 3600 500 Penn
Elizabeth 46 F Penn [in my family records, Elizabeth Reese b. Mecungie, Pa, 10-17-1883]
Margaret 26 F NY
Kati 23 F NY
Elizabeth 21 F
Salome 18 M [ the census definitely has an M but not sure of name but it looks like Solome.]
Mary 15 F
William 13 M
Christina 11 F
George 8 M
John 86 M retired farmer Penn [this would be Williams's father I assume.]
William H. 32 M farm laborer NY [This man is too old to be Elizabeth's son. Is he a son of William by an earlier marriage, a nephew of William? or what. My family records mention William Henry Stahl (Capt. in Union Army d. 9-15-1863). This certainly sounds like him. In any case he is listed as living in the household of William Stahl.]

1870 Lockport, Niagara, New York
Stahl William 67 Farmer 5000 b. Pennsylvania
- Elizabeth 55 b. Pennsylvania
- Margaret 34 b. New York
- Saloma 28 b. New York
- Mary 25 b. New York
- William 23 clerk in store b. New York
- Christina 21 clerk in store b. New York
- George 18 farm laborer b. New York
Ingalls Catherine 32 b. New York
- Charles 7 b. New York
- William 5 b. New York
Fisher Catherine 61 b. Pennsylvania

---------
John was one of the first millers to ship flour down the canal)17
Joh William Stahl where someone has written (on photo) that he was a Huegenots?20
John William Stahl, a couple as a young man, and a couple in 1898, the year he died. (comments on pictures.)20
and in 1898, John William Stahl died in Minneapolis after a long illness, I think it was abt a year after a fall from a ladder.20
Wife widowed bef. 1880 2

-------------------------
There's a Charles W Stahl 1836 Civil War Vet died Methodist Cemetery 1874 (fits)

Minnesota State Census, 1895

Consider this:
Bachman/Stahl marriage resulted in Christina marrying Hoster, and possibly Catherine/Cathryn/Kate marrying Ingalls (resulting in 2 children) who end up living with Mama Stahl in 1880 Census with everyone else.

Also in household:
George W Hoster (1860 - NY) (is this GW Stahl also listed in Minn. St. Census 1895)
Donald K Hoster (1888 - Minn)

A Charles W Stahl served a short while in the Union Army during the Civil War.
His wife "Elizabeth widow of Stahl, Charles W" survived him, and might possibly be Elizabeth (Bachman?) Stahl listed in 1870 (with Wm. Stahl) and 1880 (without him).
Private, Company E
Enlisted: 16 April 1861
Discharged: 20 July 1861
Length of service: 3 months, 4 days
Source: https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/K8SM-QJ3

1870 Fed. Census
William Stahl M 67y Pennsylvania
Elizabeth Stahl F 55y Pennsylvania
Margaret Stahl F 34y New York
** A Margaret Stall married Ehrhardt Auringer in 1872: location Manhattan, NY
Saloma Stahl F 28y New York
Mary Stahl F 25y New York
William Stahl M 23y New York
Christina Stahl F 21y New York
George Stahl M 18y New York
Catherine Ingalls F 32y New York
Charles Ingalls M 7y New York
William Ingalls M 5y New York
Catherine Fisher F 61y Pennsylvania

Find a Grave Memorial: Charles W. Stahl, Mifflin County, PA

1880 Fed. Census
Head Elizabeth Stahl (maiden name Bachman) Stahl F 65 Pennsylvania
Daughter Margaret Stahl F 44 New York, United States
Daughter Salome Stahl F 37 New York, United States
Daughter Mary Stahl F 34 New York, United States
Son George Stahl M 28 New York, United States
Daughter Catherine Ingalls F 42 New York, United States
Daughter Christina (Stahl) Hoster F 32 New York, United States
Son-in-law Geo. W. Hoster M 34 New York, United States
Grandson Chas. S. Ingalls M 17 New York, United States
Grandson Wm. B. Ingalls M 15 New York, United States
Granddaughter Nina E. Hoster F 4 New York, United States
Grandson Walter S. Hoster M 2 New York, United States
Sister Catherine Fisher F 72 Pennsylvania, United States

U.S.Civil War Pension Index
Name of Soldier: Stahl, Charles W
Name of Dependent: Stahl, Elizabeth
Service: A 36 PA Mil Inf.
E 25 PA, Inf.
Date of filing: 1890 July 9 (filed in PA)